ADA Compliance or Bust: How an Accessible Website Can Save Your Practice (and Your Reputation)

In an era where digital presence is paramount, law firms can’t afford to overlook website accessibility. At PaperStreet, we’ve helped hundreds of law firms navigate the complexities of ADA compliance while creating beautiful, functional websites. It’s not just about avoiding lawsuits – though that’s certainly important – it’s about expanding your reach, demonstrating your commitment to inclusion, and protecting your firm’s reputation.  Let’s dive into why ADA compliance should be at the top of your digital priority list and how to achieve it.

The Stakes Are Higher Than Ever

Picture this: You’ve invested thousands in a sleek, modern website that showcases your firm’s expertise and success stories. But there’s a problem – potential clients with disabilities can’t navigate it effectively. Not only are you missing out on business opportunities, but you’re also exposing your firm to legal risks. The irony? As legal professionals, you could find yourself on the wrong end of an accessibility lawsuit. 

According to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, digital accessibility lawsuits continue to surge, with over 3,000 filed in federal court in 2022. Law firms weren’t immune—in fact, they faced increased scrutiny given their professional obligation to understand and uphold ADA requirements. The message is clear – if you’re not prioritizing digital accessibility, you’re playing with fire.

Understanding Website Accessibility

Website accessibility means ensuring your digital presence can be used by everyone, regardless of their abilities.  This includes: 

  • Visually impaired individuals using screen readers
  • People with hearing impairments who need captions for video content
  • Those with motor disabilities who navigate using keyboard commands
  • Individuals with cognitive disabilities who require clear, consistent layouts

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) doesn’t explicitly mention websites, but courts have consistently interpreted Title III to include digital spaces as “places of public accommodations.” This interpretation means your website must be as accessible as your physical offices. 

Business Case for Accessibility

Beyond legal compliance, an accessible website offers numerous benefits:

  • Expanded Client Base – According to the CDC, approximately 61 million adults in the United States have a disability. That’s a significant portion of potential clients who might need legal services. An accessible website ensures you’re not inadvertently turning away business.
  • Enhanced Reputation – In today’s socially conscious environment, demonstrating a commitment to accessibility can significantly boost your firm’s reputation. It shows that you’re not just talking about justice and equality – you’re practicing it in every aspect of your business. 
  • Improved SEO Performance – Many accessibility features align perfectly with SEO best practices. Clear headings, descriptive alt text, and well-structured content help both users with disabilities and search engines better understand your content, potentially improving your search rankings. 

Essential Components of ADA-Compliant Website

Creating an ADA-compliant website starts with thoughtful navigation and structure. Your site should guide users naturally through your content with clear, consistent navigation menus that remain predictable across all pages. Think of it as creating a well-organized office space where everyone can find what they need without assistance

To achieve this level of accessibility, we focus on essential navigational elements:

  • Intuitive Navigation Structure – Just as your office has clear signage, your website needs consistent menus and predictable layouts that guide visitors naturally through your content
  • Logical Heading Hierarchy – We create a clear content roadmap using properly structured headings (H1, H2, H3) that help screen readers understand your content’s organization
  • Keyboard Navigation Support – For users who can’t use a mouse, we ensure every part of your site is accessible via keyboard, including convenient skip links to bypass repetitive elements

When it comes to content accessibility, every element of your site needs to communicate its purpose clearly. We implement comprehensive content features: 

    • Rich Media Accessibility – From educational videos to client testimonials, all multimedia content includes captions, transcripts, and audio descriptions
    • Visual Clarity – We maintain high contrast ratios between text and backgrounds, while ensuring all text remains readable when resized up to 200%
  • Image Descriptions – Every meaningful image includes descriptive alt text, ensuring visually impaired users don’t miss important information

The technical foundation of your site plays a crucial role in accessibility. Our development approach includes: 

  • Robust Form Design – Contact forms, client intake forms, and newsletter signups feature clear labels, helpful error messages, and keyboard-accessible inputs.
  • Document Accessibility – Your legal resources, from case studies to newsletters, are formatted for screen reader compatibility
  • Table Structure – When presenting complex data, we ensure proper table markup so screen readers can correctly navigate and announce information. 

For more advanced features, we implement sophisticated solutions that enhance everyone’s user experience. Dynamic content updates are announced appropriately through ARIA live regions, ensuring users don’t miss important changes or updates. Custom interactive features are built with accessibility baked in from the start, not added as an afterthought. 

Mobile Accessibility

According to the Pew Research Center, over 91% of Americans now own smartphones, making mobile accessibility non-negotiable. PaperStreet ensures all law firm websites we develop follow mobile accessibility best practices:

  • Touch-Friendly Targets – All interactive elements are properly sized and spaced for easy touch interaction
  • Responsive Design – Content remains accessible regardless of device or screen orientation.
  • Gesture Alternatives – Every touch-based interaction has a keyboard-accessible alternative

These technical considerations work together seamlessly to create a welcoming digital environment for all potential clients while maintaining the professional image your firm deserves.  

Looking Forward

As technology evolves and legal standards develop, website accessibility requirements will likely become more stringent. Staying ahead of these changes isn’t just about compliance – it’s about positioning your firm as a leader in inclusive legal services. Our team stays current with the latest Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) and legal requirements, ensuring your website complies with current standards and is prepared for future updates.  

Expert Implementation with PaperStreet

ADA compliance for your law firm’s website isn’t optional – it’s a crucial investment in your practice’s future. By prioritizing accessibility, you’re not just protecting yourself from litigation; you’re expanding your reach, enhancing your reputation, and demonstrating your commitment to equal access. In today’s digital age, that is not just good law – it’s good business.

For over twenty years, PaperStreet has specialized in creating ADA-compliant websites for law firms. Our approach combines technical expertise with legal industry knowledge. Partner with PaperStreet to ensure your website meets the highest accessibility standards while maintaining the professional image your firm deserves.

Blog Decorative Background

Join the Sales and Marketing News, receive our last insights, tips and best practices.

Our 7 Guarantees

Keeping 2,000+ Clients Happy Since 2001.

1
You Will Love Your Design We design to please you and your clients
2
Same-Day Support 24-hour turnaround edits during business hours
3
Free Education We provide knowledge to help you expand
4
No Hidden Charges We quote flat-rate projects
5
Own Your Site No strings attached
6
We Create Results SEO, PPC, content + design = clients
7
We Make Life Easier One agency for web, branding and marketing